Police Commissioner claims she is above the law and cannot be charged with any criminal offence in her position

Labor Magistrate throws out charges

Charges against the Queensland Police Commissioner for failing to provide regular tyre-spike training to her officers have been dismissed.

Katarina Carroll had been charged with two counts of failing to comply with her health and safety duties between January 1, 2012, and June 30, 2019. During this 7½-year period, 26 officers were injured on the job while deploying tyre spikes.

Qld Police Commissioner Katarina Carroll, from Herberton, says she cannot be prosecuted for any offence in her position

She sought to have the charges, brought by the Office of the Work Health and Safety Prosecutor, thrown out because she was not in the top job during the period alleged, and she claimed she couldn’t be charged with criminal offences in her position.

The charges were filed on February 1, 2021. The first charge relates to officers being put at risk by the Commissioner’s actions, while the second relates to risks to members of the public.

Magistrate Stephen Courtney handed down his decision at the Brisbane Magistrates Court on Thursday afternoon.

He said that after reading through the Work Health and Safety Act and The Police Service Administration Act, he found the police commissioner herself could not be a defendant.

Police Inspector John Bosnjak, brother to Commissioner Katarina Carroll, hails from the Herberton district of FNQ. He is able to be charged and was fined $500 for drink driving in 2019

“Ultimately, I am satisfied section 248 does not authorise the office of the commissioner of the police service to be named as a defendant and a complaint will be in breach of the work health and safety act,” he said.

“I am also satisfied the office of the commissioner of the police service is not otherwise a legal personality capable of being so named.”

Judge Courtney also said the particulars around practical measures of spikes were at times “inconsistent” but followed legal obligations overall.

“The particulars read together tell the commissioner what duty owed, when it failed to comply with the duty, what it did in attempting to comply with duty, what additional measures were practical … I am satisfied the particulars read as a whole satisfy those requirements,” he said. – Brisbane Times

About Editor, cairnsnews

One of the few patriots left who understands the system and how it has been totally subverted under every citizen's nose. If we can help to turn it around we will, otherwise our children will have nothing. Our investigations show there is no 'government' of the people for the people of Australia. The removal of the Crown from Australian Parliaments, followed by the incorporation of Parliaments aided by the Australia Act 1987 has left us with corporate government with policies not laws, that apply only to members of political parties and the public service. There is no law, other than the Common Law. This fact will be borne out in the near future as numerous legal challenges in place now, come to a head soon.

Posted on April 22, 2022, in ALP, Annastacia Palaszczuk, australian Labor Party, Commonwealth Constitution of Australia, Corporate Government, Courts and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink. 20 Comments.

  1. In Ukraine, Azov is a unit of “Special Tasks Patrol Police”.
    “It has been notorious for the crimes it has committed in Ukraine against civilians and Russian soldiers.”
    https://english.almayadeen.net/news/politics/japan-removes-azov-battalion-neo-nazi-designation

    Residents of #Mariupol, who managed to escape to the #DPR from the hell set up in the city by #Ukrainian nationalists, spoke about the atrocities of the #Azov militants * who tortured and killed their own compatriots.

    After the Azov Battalion was formed on 5 May 2014 it was regulated by the Ukrainian Interior Ministry as a unit of “Special Tasks Patrol Police”. Azov’s founding member Andriy Biletsky explained that he regards Israel and Japan as role models for the development of Ukraine
    Azov Battalion – Wikipedia

    Latest news sources are quoting Zelensky as saying ‘Big Israel’ is a model for post-war Ukraine.

    There is a term mentioned in the Protocol No.15 of the Learned Elders of Zion which is The “Azev-tactics”.

    The Azev significance is found in The History on the Origin of the Protocols where it states that “through Jewish members of the Russian police, minutes of the proceedings of the Basle congress in 1897 had been obtained and these were found to correspond with the Protocols.

    These Jewish members were Eno Azev and Efrom. The latter, formerly a rabbi, died in 1925 in a monastery in Serbia, where he had taken refuge; he used to tell the monks that the protocols were but a small part of Jewish plans for ruling the world and a feeble expression of their hatred of the gentiles.
    The Russian government had learned that at meetings of the B’nai Brith in New York in 1893-94, Jacob Schiff had been named chairman of the committee on the revolutionary movement in Russia.
    https://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sociopolitica/esp_sociopol_zion03.htm

    Yevno Azev was the most famous of all the Russian Socialist Revolutionaries agents provocateurs. He was a Russian terrorist and infiltrator of the Okhrana (the Tsarist political police). The History of Terrorism by Gérard Chaliand 2016 says “It was not Azev who created the terror; it was not Azev who breathed life into it; and Azev does not possess the power …”

    There’s similarity between the Azov militants and Yevno (Eno) Azev with the statements of Protocol No.15:

    “… until we come into our kingdom, we shall act in the contrary way … The most secret political plots will be known to us and will fall under our guiding hands … But if there should arise in its midst a plot, then at the head of that plot will be no other than one of our most trusted servants … We are obliged without hesitation to sacrifice individuals … When the King of Israel sets upon his sacred head the crown offered him by Europe he will become patriarch of the world”.

    Like

  2. Fed Up! – Good comment: “We are all looked upon as useless eaters by the elite cabal
    Annastacia and Katarina are joined at the hip. A healthy police force operates independently from politicians.” Maybe this link will bring more light to what kind of monsters are behind all this “Cabal, Crap”. >The second video — A Plan to Drug the Useless Eaters?< Notice Yuval Noah Harari, a history professor and adviser to WEF. https://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2022/04/25/mckinsey-fda-opioids.aspx?ui=f61649bc9b7686337154de2232c29d2fb14bf826e7c45b4bf644400a78b8c4ec&sd=20131123&cid_source=dnl&cid_medium=email&cid_content=art1HL&cid=20220425&mid=DM1154098&rid=1471171803

    Like

  3. We need Eureka Version 2.0 lets hope enough people* do know something about history, this time, it will be freedom or being hooked up to the mainframe, and if they don’t like you, yes then you will be deleted. I have realised history* is not a welcome topic on this blog, but here
    below a few Hackable video links, hope at least 1 works, they have a habit of being deleted.
    Human Microchip Implants and the Internet of Bodies.
    https://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2022/04/19/internet-of-bodies.aspx
    Humans Are Becoming Hackable.

    Humans Are Becoming Hackable1.

    Or: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hLc_7CnWkxw
    Humans Are Becoming Hackable2.

    Programmable Digital Currencies Are Next.

    Like

  4. 34 seconds in …”Golden”

    Girls will be boys in the cabal

    Like

  5. Thank you Tony,

    I agree we are collateral damage. We saw how the people where treated in the Northern NSW floods!
    Unfortunately the junior ranks of the police are collateral as well. Why else do they have to get the jab when Commissioned officers and politicians are exempt.
    We are all looked upon as useless eaters by the elite cabal
    Annastacia and Katarina are joined at the hip. A healthy police force operates independently from politicians.
    The only way out of this mess is the military…….bring on those courages ‘White Hats’
    When the “Durham Report” comes out, its going to be like a domino affect around the world including Australia.

    # SACK THEM ALLl. Put every sitting member Libs, Labs, Nats and Greens LAST on May 21st

    Like

  6. Qld fool of a muppet of police commissioner has to be escorted around Brisbane city daily with 3 plan clothes officers. The way they act, engagement with pushing there weight around, parking in bus stops to go into 7/11 store. They are driving a black unmarked jeep. She is marked person by the paranoia they stink of. Many offices have lost respect for the snr ranks, they feel no longer supported.

    Like

  7. lindesymonds: & Thanks for the Indexed Video Library, good to have it all together like that

    Like

  8. Fed Up… Commiserations. But to the Queensland cops you are just collateral damage.

    I agree with you, we need a clean-up to remove the corruption and incompetence, which is now endemic. But we no longer have Rule of Law. We have no judiciary of integrity. A dozen years ago, a Brisbane magistrate ruled she is Immune to the law. This lawlessness is not new.

    But you need to appreciate the gravity of what you are saying. There is only one recourse left for the people… removing the corruption by force, which is the technical term for civil war.

    That is where most Australians are stuck. The knowledge that the answer must come from each individual. This prospect terrifies them, so they are standing still like a deer in the headlights. Others are so naive they think that divine incantations will do the job for them, Others, that peaceful protest will force the psychopaths to step down in shame.

    I thinks it’s called “A Rock and a Hard Place”.

    Like

  9. Our police have gone from critical thinkers to poorly trained Adrenaline junkie Robo cops thanks to the cabal that have taken over the West
    I was sitting in a line of traffic to go up to Mt Tamborine. We where in a line of about 20 stationary cars because they are building a bridge on Howard Creek and have traffic lights in place because the Qld Government won’t fork out for people to man this because they are too stingy
    Cut a long story short the QLD police chased a young offender (from Maroochy) into the parked traffic on the road up to Mt Tamborine. What happened to calling off a chase when it becomes dangerous to civilians?….Where the Fk was the police helicopter to assist the police. Unfortunately he landed right next to my car after hitting a poor traumatised woman in line that pulled off to the left as she thought it was the Ambo’s….
    I had my window down sitting in the passengers seat waiting patiently for the light to changed.
    We had the criminal scum that landed I don’t know how next to me and as soon as I saw the police jump from their vehicle I told my partner to turn on the car so I could wind up my window and get the hell out of the way. Unfortunately he couldn’t because Robo cops ran in front of our car and had their batterns drawn and proceeded to smash the window of criminal scum parked next to me spraying me with glass.
    I am still pick glass out of my eyes, nose ,ears and butt cheeks?…I don’t know how the hell it got there!
    I can’t go to hospital because the pig in lipstick premiere won’t let the unjabbed unless they bleeding from the throat…and lets face it, I would be better off going to a witch doctor because at least I would make it out alive
    I was once a part of the police family. I am not an officer but I know the shit they have to put up with.
    Apparently someones flash Mercedes got stolen from a shopping centre at maroochy by a 15 y/o who listens to too much hiphop going by how he was dressed.
    I wonder if it was someones shitbox that would have received the same royal treatment
    I was expecting a bank holdup criminal scum with hostages in the car.
    I have always respected the police for the difficult job they have. The many police that where once apart of my family have been the salt of the earth.
    We need a big clean out Australia wide and we need to start it from the top

    Like

  10. Normally I have experienced no natural justice is within the law, “But for a long time we have NO Law at all.” Then again when money keeps on flowing “Hm Hm,” you be fine.

    Like

  11. She says she wasn’t in the top job when the incidents occurred, so shouldn’t be charged, OK, probably agree with that. BUT then claims she is immune from criminal charges in her position. What a load of crap. But of course, The Queen and her fellow ‘top cops’ are immune from taking the Death Jab. It figures. CORRUPT.

    Like

  12. Labour Magistrate Stephen is clearly ‘in the know’ as to what is coming down the pipeline. To wit he upheld the right of the top cop to basically tell the court to F(arce) off. The exact quote is: ‘in my position I can not be prosecuted for any offense’. Obviously in the Cressida Dick mould, the imperious Katrina is above the rule of mere laws.

    This is an important ruling because here is what is in the pipeline

    “We won’t let you get away with it. We are coming for you! We have the stamina to hound you down and we damn well will!” In the Senate, Australian Senator Malcolm Roberts puts PM Scott Morrison, Health Minister Greg Hunt and other covid criminals on notice.

    When the time comes, I am sure they will all be running an ‘I am above the law’ defense.

    https://drtrozzi.org/2022/04/17/we-are-coming-for-you-australan-sen-malcolm-roberts-warns/
    CoVID criminals put on notice by Sen Malcolm Roberts

    https://drtrozzi.org/2022/04/17/australia-covid-under-question-inquiry-complete-video-collection/

    CoVID Under Question Complete Video Collection. A cross-party inquiry hosted by Senator malcolm Roberts into the Australian government’s response to CoVID 19. March 23 2022. Here is the indexed video library of the doctors, scientists experts
    and others who spoke at the event. Introduction by Sen Malcolm Roberts.

    Liked by 1 person

  13. Is that thing even a she?

    Like

  14. So how does that work. Where did that law come from ? And why ? After all she is in charge. Surely it is a neglect of duty, 26 officers injured, what are they waiting for a death ? Why cannot she be a defendant ? And what about OHS ? What a bad decision.

    Like

  15. Hi Editor The Treasonous Political Parties joined the Status of the Treasonous Commonwealth of Australia as a sovereign, independent and federal nation. This creates the system where Political Parties, Banks, their Treasonous Judiciary and their Mercenaries Protectors (Police) are above the Law. Bring back Our Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1901 as Proclaimed and Gazetted which is a Common Law of England Contract and all the Treasonous Bastards above will face Common Law of England Courts. Treason still holds the Death Penalty. Dick

    Like

  16. Magistrate Stephen Courtney failed to make clear to the public the reasons for his decision.

    The principle of bureaucratic accountability basically says “The buck stops here” pointing to the highest officer in the service in question. So, if officers have been injured when laying road spikes, this clearly reflects inadequate safety training OR that the practice itself is intrinsically unsafe; both of which the most senior police officer is paid to assess.

    Obviously, this has not happened, so either the prosecutor targeted the wrong senior officer, or the magistrate is saying nobody is responsible.

    Justice must be seen to be done and this magistrate failed also in this regard.

    Australia needs a nationwide clean-up of incompetent judges and magistrates. Followed up by a review of senior police, especially in Queensland.

    Liked by 1 person

  17. She needs hanging

    Like

  18. She’s absolutely right but only because the same entity that stymied the charges against Julia Gillard will step forward again and protect the bitch.
    Also there’s not a COURT-OF-JUSTICE anywhere in the country they’re all unidroit tribunals, appointed by,and administered by the criminal government, hence we have “criminal law”.

    Like

  19. She needs to put down the crack pipe. No one is above the law.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: